"Does Helping the Planet Hurt the Poor? " Open Discussion

Posted by Brettyg On Wednesday, January 26, 2011
(Photo from Wall Street Journal)

In their Saturday Essay column, The Wall Street Journal asked Peter Singer and Bjorn Lomberg, two global development experts, to respond to this question: Does Helping the Planet Hurt the Poor?

Peter Singer summed up his response as this

"No, if the West Makes Sacrifices."

Bjorn Lomberg summed up his response as this

"Yes, if We Listen to Green Extremists"

The opposing beliefs of the two is captured in this statement by Bjorn Lomberg"

"...Fortunately, there is a more sensible way forward that could use the same $250 billion that the European Union is expecting to waste annually on ineffective global warming policies. First, we should spend about $100 billion a year on research and development to make green energy cheaper and more widely available. Mr. Singer argues that it is not ethically defensible just to hope for a "technological miracle" that will allow us to end our reliance on fossil fuels..."

Lomberg believes that were going to spend too much money on policies that have to little return on investment and that this capital can be used to help the impoverished with programs that have been time tested.

I would love to open this to the public to see where Heifer supporters stand. Click here for link to Wall Street Journal piece.
Bookmark and Share

0 Response to ""Does Helping the Planet Hurt the Poor? " Open Discussion"

Post a Comment

Note: All comments will be reviewed for appropriateness before they are posted.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Heifer Empowers Women

Join Heifer in Brooklyn

Upcoming Events

What We're Saying on Twitter

About Us

This blog is the online home to a grassroots volunteer group with a common goal of fulfilling Heifer International's basic mission - "To end hunger and save the earth by passing on the gift to others.” We are an extension of Heifer International and together we are improving our world and the lives of resource-poor families while building the foundation for a peaceful world in practical, down-to-earth ways.